April 24, 2024

What Is Proof of Emotional Distress?

An anxiety-ridden man leans on a wooden table

Emotional distress is a significant yet often underestimated aspect of personal injury law. An individual's well-being is profoundly affected when they experience emotional distress due to the actions of others. But what qualifies as "evidence of emotional distress," and how does it fit into the legal process? 

 Keep reading to understand emotional distress, its importance in personal injury cases, and how Savannah law firm Oliver Maner can provide expert assistance.

The Significance of Emotional Distress

Emotional distress, also known as psychological distress or mental anguish, encompasses the emotional and psychological pain an individual experiences due to specific events or circumstances. These distressing events can range from accidents and injuries to intentional acts like harassment, defamation or invasion of privacy.

 Emotional distress often presents as:

  • Anxiety
  • Depression
  • Fear
  • Grief
  • Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)
  • Sleep disturbances
  • Loss of enjoyment of life

 It is important to understand that emotional distress can be as incapacitating as physical injuries and profoundly affect an individual's daily life, relationships, and overall well-being.

Establishing Proof of Emotional Distress in Personal Injury Cases

Demonstrating emotional distress within a legal framework can pose challenges. Unlike physical injuries, emotional distress is not as visibly evident or quantifiable. To substantiate a valid claim for emotional distress, several essential elements need to be proven:

Duty of Care

At the core of every personal injury lawsuit, particularly those that encompass emotional distress, lies the fundamental concept of "duty of care." This principle signifies that the defendant held responsibility toward the plaintiff, creating a legal obligation to behave reasonably and prevent harm to the plaintiff. This forms the foundation for proving negligence or misconduct on the defendant's part.

Breach of Duty

Establishing a breach of duty is important in demonstrating emotional distress. It is essential to convey that the defendant violated their duty of care through negligence, recklessness or intentional misconduct. This element of the claim underscores the defendant's departure from the legally mandated standard of behavior, which directly led to the plaintiff's emotional anguish.


Causation is the linchpin connecting the defendant's actions or negligence to the plaintiff's emotional distress. Establishing a clear cause-and-effect relationship is crucial. In essence, it must be demonstrated that the defendant's actions were the direct catalyst for the plaintiff's emotional anguish. This often necessitates comprehensive evidence and expert testimony to substantiate the claims.

Severe Emotional Distress

In an emotional distress claim, the plaintiff must demonstrate the severity of the distress experienced, which is one of the most crucial components. It is insufficient to establish mild distress or annoyance; the emotional suffering must be significant and severe. The plaintiff must prove that their distress has profoundly impacted their life, affecting their mental and emotional well-being.

Documentation and Evidence

Gathering compelling evidence is fundamental to constructing a robust case for emotional distress. The documentation should encompass a comprehensive range of materials, including medical records, therapy or counseling records, eyewitness testimonies, and expert witness testimony. These pieces of evidence authenticate and validate the claims, providing a solid foundation for the case.

Corroborating Evidence

While the elements mentioned above form the backbone of the emotional distress claim, corroborating evidence can further bolster the credibility of the assertions. This additional evidence may encompass photographs, videos or other documentation substantiating the narrative, rendering it more convincing and compelling to the court.

Varieties of Cases Involving Emotional Distress

Emotional distress is a multifaceted and frequently underestimated component of various legal cases. It can manifest in various scenarios and significantly impact an individual's mental and emotional well-being. Let's delve deeper into the cases where emotional distress plays a central role:

Personal Injury Claims

Personal injury cases encompass many different incidents, such as car accidents, slips and falls, and medical malpractice. In numerous instances, emotional distress naturally accompanies physical injuries. Consider a car accident victim, for example. They grapple with bodily harm and may experience psychological trauma linked to the accident. Demonstrating emotional distress in personal injury claims is crucial to demonstrate the comprehensive impact of the incident on the victim's life.

Workplace Harassment or Discrimination

Ideally, the workplace should foster productivity and personal growth. Sadly, it becomes a source of emotional anguish for some, due to workplace harassment or discrimination. Employees enduring such conditions may suffer severe emotional distress. Harassment, discrimination, or bullying can create a hostile work environment that leads to various emotional symptoms, including anxiety, depression and constant fear.

Proving emotional distress in workplace harassment or discrimination cases is fundamental to obtaining the rightful compensation and ensuring that the emotional toll is acknowledged as part of the victim's suffering.


Defamation lawsuits center on the spread of untrue claims that tarnish someone's reputation. These inaccurate statements can deeply affect a person's life, causing reputational harm and emotional distress. The emotional suffering in defamation cases can be notably severe, particularly when serious repercussions like job loss or damaged personal relationships occur. 

Proving that emotional distress has occurred is essential during defamation cases when pursuing remediation and recognizing the harm caused by false statements.

Wrongful Death Cases

Wrongful death cases entail the tragic loss of a loved one due to another party's negligence or intentional actions. Surviving family members often experience profound emotional distress following the sudden passing of their loved one. The grief, anger and suffering that ensues can be overwhelming. 

Emotional distress in wrongful death cases extends beyond the deceased individual; it encompasses the anguish and emotional pain endured by those left behind. Recognizing and addressing this emotional distress is essential for seeking justice and supporting the grieving family.

The Importance of Legal Representation

Cases involving emotional distress demand an in-depth understanding of the legal system and the ability to communicate and demonstrate the severity of the pain effectively suffered. Oliver Maner has an established record of successfully managing personal injury cases, including those involving emotional distress. Their expertise, dedication and commitment to their clients sets them apart in the legal field.

Emotional distress is a significant element in personal injury cases that merits recognition and compensation under the law. If you have suffered emotional distress due to the actions of others, it's advisable to seek legal assistance.

 Opting for Oliver Maner LLP is a prudent choice. Our firm specializes in personal injury law and boasts a track record of success. Get in touch with our team to pursue the compensation and closure you deserve. Your emotional well-being is essential, and with the right legal representation, you can seek justice for the distress you've endured.

Recent Posts